Methods for flange leakage checking by Pressure Equivalent Method using Caesar II

Hopefully, all of you have gone through my post on Methods for checking flange leakage. In that article, I had mentioned the theoretical background (analysis criteria, the basic theory behind flange leakage checking, analysis methodology, etc.) for checking flange leakage. So click here to refer to the article once again before you proceed with this article. In this current write-up, I will explain the step-by-step method for performing flange leakage analysis methodology following the Pressure Equivalent Method using Caesar II. Click here to check the ASME Section VIII method.

flange leakage checking
Fig. 1: Typical flange in Caesar II model

Caesar II methodology for Pressure Equivalent method

Model the complete stress system from the stress isometric. It’s preferable to model each flange separately for analysis. For valve assembly, model the flanges and valves separately. Once the modeling is complete select the flanges that need to analyzed as per the pressure equivalent method. In Fig. 1, node 20-30 and node 30-40 denote the flange assembly. Node 30 is the interface point of both the flanges where flange leakage checking is required.

Inputs for Flange Analysis

Now refer to the Fig. 2 provided below. Click on Flange checks button (Checkbox) which will activate the flange input module of Caesar II Input Screen. Now select the Flange Node(From/To/Both) and Calculation Type as shown in Fig. 2. From/To to be selected such that node 30 as mentioned-above is selected in the model. For example as node 30 is the interface point, “To” need to be selected in element 20-30 and “From” to be selected for element 30-40. Both is normally selected for flanged valves keeping the valve as active. As we are performing Pressure Equivalent method, Peq need to be selected.

Next, Select Flange Class/Grade through ‘Read from File’ button and refer to ASME B 16.5/ ASME B 16.47 material tables. Select flange pressure class and material grade along with governing ASBE B 16.5 code with year.

Required data will automatically be filled in. By default, the value of G will be taken as the mean gasket diameter. Users can cross-check and update the value of G as per ASME B 16.20 & ASME Sec. VIII Div. 1, Appendix 2, Table 2-5-2. based on the following equation:

  • b0 = 1/4, G = Mean diameter of the gasket contact face
  • b0 > 1/4, G = Outside diameter of gasket contact face less 2b, b=basic gasket width from code. check the above mentioned code table for more details.
Caesar II Spread sheet typical input
Fig. 2: Caesar II Spread sheet typical input

Flange Leakage Checking Setting and Output Result

Now go to the load case editor of Caesar II and select the temperature at which flange leakage checking to be performed as shown in Fig. 3. Normally, flange leakage is performed at the maximum design temperature. So, select that temperature. Now run the analysis to check the results. In case the calculated flange stress exceeds the allowable results will be shown in red color. The report will show the % ratio of the calculated equivalent pressure with respect to allowable. Check Fig. 4 for output results.

Load Case Options module in Caesar II
Fig. 3: Load Case Options module in Caesar II
Fig. 4: Caesar II flange leakage pressure equivalent output 

                                   

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Anup Kumar Dey

I am a Mechanical Engineer turned into a Piping Engineer. Currently, I work in a reputed MNC as a Senior Piping Stress Engineer. I am very much passionate about blogging and always tried to do unique things. This website is my first venture into the world of blogging with the aim of connecting with other piping engineers around the world.

6 thoughts on “Methods for flange leakage checking by Pressure Equivalent Method using Caesar II

  1. Dear Sirs,

    Thank you for this reference, as currently I am calculating this Pe using caesar but why caesar using force perpendicular to my axis instead of axial force, let say my piping is in z direction (as axial = Fz) but caesar using force Fx for this calculation?

    Thanks

  2. Hi Anup
    When i model a valve or flange use Cadworx database, the dimension and weight of valves/flange different with vendor data. How can I create an other databases for valves/flange or modify the database of Cadworx (I modify the cadworx catalog in C:\ProgramData\Intergraph CAS\CAESAR II\5.30 but the dimension and weight of valves/flange didn’t change in model)

  3. Dear Sir/Madam

    your website is so informative and I appreciate it.
    in this article figures 2~4 have not loaded and I was wondering if you could send me these figures.

    thank you in advance.
    AZ

  4. GRP piping and metal lap-joint flange check

    i have a GRP system and lap-joint flanges (metal flanges and GRP stub-end).

    The flanges connect the two stub-ends and between every couple of metal flange there are the two GRP stub-end ends, so metal flange don’t connect direcly, there is GRP between them.

    How to perform flange check in this situation?

    thank you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts