Piping systems under vacuum condition, Jacketed Piping, Offshore pipelines, piping inside equipment, etc. are subjected to both internal as well as external pressure. Contrary to the internal pressure, external pressure compresses the material, and Failure of piping under squeezing action can occur at lower pressure. This is due to elastic buckling. The pipe geometry is weaker in compression than in tension and failure can occur well below the yield point under the influence of external pressure. So, the piping system must be designed to withstand external pressure.
External pressure pipe wall thickness calculation must be performed for all lines having possibility to external pressure or vacuum pressure. By preliminary understanding it may seem that as the internal design pressure is usually more than the external design pressure, so designing for internal pressure will take care of the external pressure design thickness as well. But this is not the case. As the piping system behaves differently under vacuum or external pressure condition. Due to the buckling consideration all design philosophy changes for external pressure design thickness calculation.
For straight pipe under external pressure, two checks are performed:
- First is the membrane stress check in accordance with pipe thickness calculation based on internal pressure Eq. (3a) [or (3b)] of ASME B31.3 (Clause 304.1.2).
- The second check is a buckling check (As specified in Clause 304.1.3 of ASME B 31.3) in accordance with the external pressure design rules outlined in ASME BPVC, Section VIII, Division 1, UG-28 through UG-30. The design length, L, the running centerline length between any two sections stiffened in accordance with UG-29 means the length between flanges, heads, stiffeners, etc.
In this article, we will explore the external pressure pipe thickness calculation steps with an example problem.
External Pressure Pipe Wall Thickness Methodology
In external pressure design pipe thickness calculation, initially a pipe thickness is calculated based on internal pressure condition. Please click here to explore the steps required for pipe wall thickness calculation for internal pressure using ASME B 31.3.
Once the pipe thickness is selected based on internal pressure, that pipe thickness is checked with respect to buckling following ASME BPVC UG-28 rules to find if that thickness is sufficient for external pressure conditions. So, this is basically verification of the selected pipe thickness as per ASME B 31.3, clause 304.1.3, and ASME BPV Code, Section VIII, Division 1, UG 28.
ASME BPV code provides two separate procedures for calculating the minimum required thickness, for Do/t >= 10 and Do/t <10. Here Do=Outside Diameter of Pipe and t=Minimum required thickness.
Buckling pressure calculations in ASME BPVC, Section VIII, Division 1 requires the calculation of two parameters; A and B.
- Parameter A is a function of geometry and
- Parameter B depends on A and the material property curve. The charts that provide the parameter B account for plasticity between the proportional limit of the stress-strain curve and the 0.2% offset yield stress.
Example Problem for External Pressure Design Pipe Thickness Calculation
We will consider a 32″ Carbon Steel Pipe with 31.75 mm thickness with the following parameters for external pressure design thickness calculation.
- P : External Pressure = 15 psi Section
- Do: Outside Diameter of pipe = 813 mm for 32″ pipe (as per ASME B36.10M)
- L: Assumed unstiffened length of pipe = 12000 mm (472.4 inches), (based on the piping layout for calculation purpose).
- T: Selected Pipe wall thickness based on internal pressure = 31.75 mm;
- t: Selected Thickness less mill tolerance of 0.3 mm and corrosion allowance of 3 mm = 28.45 mm (1.12 inch)
- T : Design temperature = 149 Deg. C
- Y: SMYS of the material = 35000 psi
- E: modulus of elasticity of the material at design temperature = 294000000 psi
External Pressure Design Pipe Thickness Verification Steps
Step-1: Calculation of Do/t
Calculate Do/t; Here Do=32″ and t=1.12 “. So Do/t=32/1.12=28.57 which is greater than 10.
So we will follow first method of ASME Sec VIII Div 1.
Step-2: Finding L/Do
Here, L=472.4″ and Do=32″; Hence L/Do=14.76- approximately 15
Step-3: Finding Factor A
Finding Factor A from Fig. G of ASME Sec II, Sub part 3, Part D,
For finding factor A, Enter ASME BPVC Section II, Part D, Subpart 3, Figure G at the value of L/Do and Do/t determined in Step 1 and 2. The figure is reproduced below in Fig. 1 for sample reference purpose.
From the Fig.1; The factor A=0.00135.
Step-4: Finding Factor B
Determining value of Factor B
Using the values of A calculated in step 3 (A=0.00135 for our case), enter the applicable material chart in subpart 3 of Section II, Part D.
As our material is CS with SMYS=35000 psi, we have to refer Fig. CS-2. (Reproduced in Fig. 2 for reference)
From the curve value of Factor B=13200.
In cases where the value of A falls to the right of the end of the material/temperature line, assume an intersection with the horizontal projection of the upper end of the material/temperature line. If tabular values are used, the last (maximum) tabulated value shall be used.
Step-5: Calculating Maximum Allowable External Working Pressure, Pa
Calculation of Maximum Allowable External Working Pressure Pa
Now, Using this value of B (as calculated in Step-4), calculate the value of the maximum allowable external working pressure Pa using the following equation (Fig. 3):
Since Pa (606.89 psi) > P (15 psi), the selected pipe wall thickness can withstand full vacuum. So our pipe is safe for a full vacuum condition.
Few more useful Resources for you.